The Case Against Outsourced SEO

About a week ago I got a phone call from a collegeOn-Site Optimization and Site Structure - this is what
buddy of mine named Paul who runs a soon-to-launchmost people think of when they think of SEO. What
online business. Here's how the conversation went:changes should be made to your site so that search
Paul: "We want to hire your company to do the SEOengine spiders have the best chance of crawling it,
for us. Whatever the price is, we can afford it."understanding the content, and ranking you
Me: "Tell me a little more about your company andaccordingly. Most often, this involves changes to Title
exactly what you expect to achieve from search."META tags, cleaning up source code so that it's
Paul: "We want to rank #1 in Google forproper HTML, moving CSS and Javascript to external
EVERYTHING in our industry, and I know you can dofiles, adding sitemaps, modifying internal linking
it for us."structure and anchor text, and several other
Me: "I'd be happy to consult with your team to makestandard changes that eliminate all potential crawling
sure you understand the principles of SEO and getand indexing issues. This is best done by your
off on the right foot, but I think you're better offprogrammer(s) so that they understand the
doing the work yourself."importance of the changes and make them part of
He was perplexed. Why wouldn't we want to taketheir routine in the future. These changes can be
on his SEO work? It has nothing to do with him orsuggested by a consultant, but will only really be
his company. It has everything to do with thesuccessful if programmers are on board.
misunderstood nature of what it takes toLink building - this is probably the second most
consistently rank high in natural search. The absolutecommon task associated with SEO. By now you
best companies I've worked with make everyalready know that you need one-way incoming links
decision with SEO in mind. Everyone in theirfrom relevant sites with applicable anchor text to
organization - from management to programmers torank high. Many outsourced SEO firms will either
marketing - is thinking about the search impact ofengage in elaborate link exchanges or purchase paid
their decisions. For that reason it makes sense to hirelinks for you: both of which are obsolete in terms of
a consultant or to learn it yourself, but not to hire anhaving any positive impact in your rankings, and now
outside firm to outsource your entire SEO campaigncan potentially penalize you. The best one-way link
to.building techniques - press releases, content
Most of the time when companies outsource SEOsyndication, blogging, product syndication, viral videos,
they do it with the mentality of "here you go, youetc - all require a LOT of input from you to be
handle it, we expect results." They view it as ansuccessful. Most of the time they should be
entirely separate entity and not as a core value thatintegrated into your existing marketing plan to have
needs to be instilled in their organization to bethe highest chance to thrive. For example, most
successful. That's why outsourced SEO just doesn'tcompanies already issue press releases when they
work: your organization still makes decisions the oldhave newsworthy announcements so it's a natural
way.extension to email the release to online news sites
How will this programming change impact our searchand blogs, and to use an online distribution service. I
results? Can we build link-building into our marketingthink successful link building is best done by your
campaign? What adjustments can we make so thatmarketing department as part of your overall
both are working in harmony to achieve ourmarketing strategy. It's fine to have a consultant help
objectives as a company and rank as high as weput the plan together, but the actual implementation
can? There is no incentive to learn about search ifof the plan should be done by you.
someone else is handling it for you, and consequentlyAnalytics - this involves the measurement and
you probably won't be asking these importanttracking of your sites' SEO and marketing campaign.
questions when making a critical business decision.Previously, this could be tedious for small sites and I
Paul was still a bit confused with that answer. So let'smight have recommended outsourcing. But with the
take a closer look at some of the key componentsnew version of Google Analytics, a properly
necessary for SEO success and what needs to takeconfigured account will tell you everything you need
place for them to be accomplished:to know about where every single sale on your site
Keyword Research - this entails researching howcame from. Your programmer or consultant should be
frequently phrases relevant to your site areable to set it up for you and configure the reports to
searched. I like to use the SEO-Book tool or the freetrack only the most important metrics for your
version of Wordtracker. Keyword research isorganization. I also like to track incoming links and
important because it will impact your site structure,search engine rankings for a site (two things that
title tags (widely regarded as the most influentialAnalytics does not track), but those can easily be
factor in how high you rank), and will help identifytracked with the Marketleap Link Checker and Digital
opportunities in your industry (if a term is searched aPoint Keyword Tracker (both of which can be found
lot but there aren't a lot of good results, you maywith a quick Google search).
have just identified a great expansion opportunity forIn the end, whether you decide to hire a consultant
your company). This is best done by either aor tackle SEO internally with the vast information
consultant or the internal head of your SEOavailable online, you still need to make SEO part of
campaign, which should be someone inyour organizations objectives for it to be a success:
upper-management.something that outsourcing usually doesn't do.